I agree that through freak shows, many of the “colored freaks” were subjected to the “modern disciplines of scientific and mass-cultural scrutiny.” And as Reiss mentioned, the whole process, “set in place some of the underlying conceptual structures of racism for the next two centuries.” Again I agree; however, I think many of the events that resulted from the end of the Civil War or more specifically the ending of slavery—Emancipation Proclamation or the Thirteenth Amendment—had equal weight if not more in contributing to the oppression of African Americans. Therefore, I think the Civil War and its consequences were worthy of at least mentioning. So one could say the whole process (The Civil War and the events that followed) set in place some of the underlying conceptual structures of racism for the next two centuries. And then mention that freak shows and their contribution to Science indirectly or even directly reinforced such underlying conceptual structures of racism. Slavery was no longer legal at the end of the Civil War, and racism became more developed , a complex term with many connotations. Why did racism develop? It needed to in order to keep African Americans oppressed, and to act as a replacement for slavery. Racism was a means to oppress, a tool. Science was used as further justification to oppress; therefore it contributed to racism. I think the structure that racism rested on in the United States was the Emancipation Proclamation.
Domalski, Josh
Josh,
ReplyDeleteI think you are correct in stating that Reiss argues that spectacles from popular entertainment--such as the display of freaks--played a significant role in both creating and reinforcing emerging notions of race in the nineteenth century. I think no historian would deny that the tensions leading up to the Civil War, the war itself, and its aftermath played a significant role in shaping notions of race, however in the nineteenth century we see race becoming a major framework within society used to place identities in a social hierarchy. Therefore, ideas of race are coming from multiple places in society--including the freak show and its intimate connection to the emerging professions of science and medicine.